1. THIN DESCRIPTION: Consider the ritual practice of identifying “hot” and “cold” things within the Abelam society and offer a “thin” description of this practice. (5 pts)
Even for a thin description, the starting point for describing this categorization of activities into “hot” and “cold” things must be the central nature of the yam to this culture.
The yam is of central importance to the Abelam, providing not just sustenance but also represents a man’s status and success in society. A lot of energy is put into growing large healthy yams and this shapes their behavior patterns. Things that hurt yams, things like conflict and emotion and aggression, are considered “hot” and discouraged. This can include war, sex, and hunting and butchering animals. Helpful behaviors, such as working the yam plots and maintaining a positive, peaceful environment, are good “cold” behaviors. Hot behaviors can only occur after a harvest and before the growing season starts again.
2. THICK DESCRIPTION: Now consider this practice a bit deeper and offer a “thick” description of this practice, focusing on explaining the *beliefs* of the individuals in this culture and *why* they (as individuals) practice these rituals. Try to adopt an "emic" approach based upon Scaglion's article. (5 pts)
The Abelam believe that yams are far more than food. Each family has maintained and perpetuated lines of yams over many generations and so they are directly connected to that family. Yams are even seen as representing the human body (and will even be dressed up during ceremonies). If the yams suffer, the family will also suffer, so ensuring that they thrive is crucial for multiple reasons, both biological and spiritual. Men compete for status using their yams, seeking to grow bigger yams, which they use in competitions and as “gifts”, though these “gifts” are primarily ways of demonstrating their skill in raising yams and other men must then gift back another large yam to maintain status.
The Abelam also believe that yams don’t like things that are labeled as “hot” and these behaviors are taboo while growing yams. This includes things like conflict, which can include internal conflict but also war with other communities. Another “hot” behavior is hunting and butchering animals. Finally, the fertility of women is also considered to be “hot”, so interacting with women (including having sex) are also taboo. A man who has had sex with a woman is considered to be unclean and dangerous to the yam plants. These hot behaviors are avoided from the start of planting season until harvest. After harvest, these taboos are removed and it is during this time that people can have sex, hunt, and engage in conflict, including wars with other communities.
3. FUNCTIONAL APPROACH: Let’s break this down into a few parts:
- Identify which behaviors are ‘hot’ or ‘cold’ for the Abelam. (5 pts)
Hot: Anything involving aggression and conflict. This can be wars, internal conflicts, sex, and hunting/butchering animals.
Cold: Peaceful behaviors, including working the yam plots. Men avoid contact with women.
- What taboo behaviors can you identify in relation to these concepts of “cold” and “hot” behaviors? (5 pts).
ALL behaviors labeled as “hot” are taboo *during* the planting season until after harvest. Note that no “cold” behavior is taboo because they don’t have the potential to cause harm like “hot” behaviors.
- Consider the annual cycle of this ‘hot/cold’ ritual and offer three different benefits or functions that enhance the lives of the Abelam and increase their survival/success in their environment. (5 pts each or 15 pts total).
There are many functions but I want to dig deeper past the functions that are apparent from an “emic” (thick description) view and highlight more “big picture” functions that result from this that the Abelam might not be aware of:
1. Social/behavioral control: These taboos set up behavioral rules that bring people’s attention away from actions that would distract from care of the yams. Fighting conflicts, hunting, and sex are all time spent away from making sure the yams thrive. Moreover, conflict/wars can actually *damage* the crops, so it is to the benefit of the community to discourage conflicts like this.
2. Ecological recovery: The taboo on hunting benefits the animal populations that serve a protein/fat source for the Abelam. Hunting year round might decimate their populations. Observing a hunting ban for six months allow these populations to recover, reproduce and grow, which in turn benefits the Abelam.
3. Birth control/Birth timing: The ban on sex for that 6 month span of time acts as a form of birth control for the women. Instead of potentially getting pregnant and giving birth annually, the sex taboo means they are only likely to get pregnant every two years. Moreover, this practice times births to the “cold” season when the yams are being grown. This is the time where conflict is taboo. That means that both the yams AND women and babies benefit from this time of peace which helps with reproductive success.
- Do you think the Abelam are aware of these functions? Do they need to be aware of them in order for them to benefit from these behaviors? (5 pts)
We only have Scaglion’s article to make a judgment on this and the topics of discussion between the author and the Abelam suggest that their focus is on the benefit to the yams (and to the men who grow them). We don’t see an indication that they are aware of these other “big picture” function (although I suspect the women are well aware of the “birth control” function). I would have liked Scaglion to talk to the women of the community a bit more to see if they have more functional awareness than the men.
But it is important to recognize that humans don’t need to be aware of functions to benefit from them. This is not surprising when you consider non-human populations. They have their own behavioral practices which benefit their survival and reproduction. They don’t behave *because* that is the functional benefit. They have evolved to behave that way. The same thought process can be applied to human populations. Understanding of a behavior is not necessary in order to behave that way.
4. CONCLUSION: Compare the three approaches explored in this assignment (thin description, thick description and functionalism). What advantages do any of them have over the others? Do you have a preferred approach? Explain your answer. (10 pts)
As is the case with many things in cultural anthropology, every view
point can provide different advantages and benefits. “Thin” descriptions are generally more useful
when communicating summaries. “Thick”
descriptions provide us with an “insider’s” view of a practice. The “functional”
approach gives us the “outsider’s” view point and can give us a broader, “big
picture” perspective, including insights into how these behaviors interact with
the surrounding environment and other populations.
The functional approach actually *includes* the emic view of the “thick
description”. It is the starting place
for exploring function. You MUST
understand the “insider” beliefs and perspectives before stepping back to
explore the “etic” view to gather the broader perspective. So with the functional approach, you are
getting two perspectives in one.
No comments:
Post a Comment