Welcome to my Anthropology Students from College of the Canyons! (Anthro 220)
As part of your Day 1 check-in procedures, you will need to get started setting up your own course blog on Blogger. This blog will be your tool for projects and assignments and discussions throughout the course.
Use this blog as just a sample of what you might want to do with your own blog. You aren't required to personalize it... If all you do is use the posting function, that's up to you, but have some fun with it! I do ask that you limit posts to strictly course projects for the duration of this class. After that, it is up to you what you want to do with it.
To get started, click the link to the right for the page "Setting up your own blog on Blogger". Please let me know if you have any questions. You will need to submit the url for your blog on the assignment page in Canvas on Day 1, though formatting and personalization of your blog can be done at your leisure.
In addition to setting up your blog, please also complete the following by 11:59 pm on Day 1:
- Submit comments to this post with regard to the discussion questions listed below. Please submit as comments below in the comments section, NOT on your personal blogs. Click the "Comments" link below to get started.
- Make two substantive responses within the comment thread below to posts made byCanvas other students. Please make sure to follow the course Netiquette rules (available on Blackboard under "Course Info") and specify the name of the person you are addressing in your comment. Again, these comments should go on the comment thread below, NOT on your personal blogs.
Scenario:
Way back in 1986, I had the opportunity to visit a Shinto temple in Japan and experience a formal Japanese tea ceremony. I was taking a comparative religions class and the ceremony was courtesy of my professor's Sensei. The tea ceremony was both incredible and terrifying, as there are formalized actions involving accepting the tea, turning the bowl so the "most beautiful side" was away from you, drinking the bitter tea, and then again turning the bowl so the "most beautiful side" was towards you and returning it to the woman who presented it to you. (I had NO idea which side of the bowl was the "most beautiful". It looked the same to me.)
I did NOT want to get this wrong. I didn't want to insult anyone. And the woman making the tea was very intimidating!
I survived the process, but it was the conversation after the ceremony that provided me with one of those "ah-ha" moments in my spiritual life and I wanted to share that with you here.
The Sensei invited us to sit beneath the blooming cherry blossoms after the ceremony to ask questions if we wished (or to just quietly meditate). One of the students was outwardly strongly Christian in her faith and had the following conversation with the Sensei:
Student: "I know from what we've learned in class that Buddhists do not believe in a 'heaven' as we Christians do. So where do you go when you die?"
Sensei: "We have nowhere to go."
His response seemed to sadden and worry the student, but Sensei's expression and tone indicated that he was very much at peace with his reality on this matter. Having "no where to go" after death didn't scare or concern him. This conversation was fodder for discussion in our next class, but I want to ask you to reflect on what this conversation tells you about belief systems and those who practice it.
Discussion question: If you had the chance to do so, could you explain to the student why the Sensei showed no sadness about not having a "heaven" to go to when he died? How would you do this in a way that would show respect for both of their belief systems?
I feel like I could explain the lack of sadness by saying something along the lines of "Having nowhere to go after death is a form of peace for Buddhists, and they prefer not having to continue to "exist" in a way. It's really just a bit of a difference in personal opinion." I feel like this could help the student understand that Buddhists just prefer not having to worry about a sort of conscious after death, even though it is different from her won personal beliefs.
ReplyDeleteHello Shanthi! love this take, the idea of not worrying feels right. Like yes, this that isn't smth that concerns him as a Buddhist. Smth that really stands out to me is the woman's reaction to his answer. I wonder if that was a response that she could "understand" in a way. Like is smth like peace without eternity one she could wrap her head around too?
DeleteHi Shanthi,
DeleteI think that's a really thoughtful way to explain it. You did a great job highlighting that it comes down to differences in personal beliefs without making it sound judgmental. Framing it as a sense of peace rather than something negative can definitely help others better understand the perspective. It's also helpful how you can acknowledge that it may be different from her own beliefs while still showing respect for both views.
Hello Shanthi! I'm not sure prefer is the exact correct word to use in this instance. With many beliefs there is no preference, merely perceived fact. For a Buddhist, the fact that they will not go anywhere when they die simply is, regardless of what they want to happen. This Buddhist has made peace with what he sees as an immutable part of life.
DeleteHello Shanthi,
DeleteI really liked how you explained how the sensei felt some sense of peace instead of feeling scared. I also liked how you explained how you would help explain to people with different views to understand in a very respectable way.
Someone who has been raised christen from birth has lived with the promise of heaven and eternal life for as long as they can remember. To them, it is a fact of life, an inevitable outcome. The same is true of someone raised Buddhist, who has never believed in eternal life. They have instead made peace with a finite end to life, and they have had a long time to do so. There is nothing to be sad about in the absence of a heaven when to them, there never was a heaven to begin with.
ReplyDeleteHello Morgan! Big fan of your last line, I definitely think that's the case. You cant mourn something that doesn't exist in your own world view. Very beautiful. I cant help but wonder how the girl who asked the question wrapped her head around his answer.
DeleteHi Morgan! I like how you mentioned specifically about how people are raised in their religions and so their differing viewpoints just seem natural to each. I definitely agree with you on that point. However, I also feel like we need to take people who convert religions into account as well, as it would probably be different for them. They likely would have considered their own beliefs and which system it lines up with before hand though.
DeleteHello Morgan! I really like your comment, very poetic. I find frequently that disagreements and misunderstandings come from the difference in knowledge between the two parties. While a Christian might find it horrifying to cease to exist in death, due to their perceived knowledge of heaven, a Buddhist, with their perceived knowledge would find the end reassuring.
DeleteHi Morgan! I really liked your focus on how their different perspectives in beliefs shaped how they view the idea of there not being a heaven. To Sensei, there is no heaven at all and he finds peace in that concept, but to the student, the concept of heaven not existing is a stressor.
DeleteHi Morgan,
DeleteI really liked how you explained that people find peace in what they have belived and been taught their whole life. I agree that the sensei wasn't sad because in his culture he had accepted what he believes that happens after death. This shows how we should respect everyones beliefs.
I would think the lack of sadness comes from a form of teaching that doesn't instill life on what comes after death. like, alot of Abrahamic religions seem to require fear or anxiety on the concept of death and what comes after- lowkey baked into its foundation, where as Buddhism (from what I'm assuming is this mans experience) seems to be taught with certainty of an end. Like death is inevitable, and rather than coordinating ones life for the preparation of eternity, he believes that what he accomplishes here will simply be done. Its belief in eventual forever with God, and the other is the belief that they are already here, with you.
ReplyDeleteHi Wortani! I really like how you went into the belief difference between the two. I totally agree with you, and I feel like the belief system's influence the way they live their lives. Therefore, the Buddhist doesn't fear death because they know that they have this one life to live. Its definitely a fascinating perspective. I also like how you phrased your last sentence, I feel like it makes it very clear the difference.
DeleteHi Wortani,
DeleteYou brought up some interesting points. I like how you explained that different beliefs can shape how people view death, especially the Buddhist focus on accepting the present. I'd just add that not all Abrahamic beliefs center on fear; many emphasize hope, too. Overall, a thoughtful explanation!
Hi Wortani,
DeleteI really liked your take on this and you explained it wonderfully, and easily digestible to someone who had been born and raised on a certain belief system.
Hi Wortani,
DeleteYou're completely right that a lot of Abrahamic religions have a lot of death anxiety sort of baked into its foundation. In Catholicism (which I grew up as), there's always this pressure on you to be the best possible version of yourself to be able to achieve heaven. And it's a great sentiment to be the best version of yourself, but it has this unintended effect of pressuring people into feeling guilty for self-indulgences because you're supposed to be always selfless and kind to others. That's not what it's supposed to be about, but that's what a lot of people (including me) end up feeling. I appreciate how you explained the differences in the two belief systems, it was very clear and brought up great points on how death is perceived differently.
Hi Wortani! This is really well worded, and I like how you thoroughly explained the difference in the meaning of death between the two beliefs. It really shows how the beliefs instilled shape our worldview and how we react to it. Someone who never grew up with the concept of fearing the end of life won't feel that fear of what comes after death.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBuddhists generally believe in finding peace with the natural cycle of life and death, rather than focusing on the idea of heaven. They emphasize living a meaningful life and contributing positively to the world. When death comes, it is seen as a natural part of existence. While there may still be some fear of dying, many believe that it ultimately brings a sense of release and peace.
ReplyDeleteHi ItsLilacXo. Great points and I like that you take an educational perspective toward the student with the questions. Maybe they just don't understand the point of view that the sensei has so education may help create understanding.
DeleteHi Lilac,
DeleteI liked your explanation as it was very nicely put especially to someone who had only been use to one certain belief system.
Hi there! I really enjoyed the way you explained your point. I definitely agree with your view, and how Buddhists focus on finding peace with the natural cycle of life and death.
DeleteHi ItsLilacXo, I like all the aspects of Buddhism you brought in to show why their beliefs lead to less fear of death. I think comparing and contrasting the beliefs of Christianity and Buddhists could make this explanation easier to understand too.
DeleteI'm not very experienced with Buddhism, so I don't want to presume to know the principles of their beliefs. If I had to explain, I would likely remind the student that different faiths have different goals and values. For Christians, achieving eternal glory in heaven is the goal, and not doing so viewed as a failure. For Buddhists, heaven is not the goal.
ReplyDeleteHi Joyce. Great point that not all religions have the same expectations and goals- sometimes we get so used to our own set of beliefs that we forget that they are just beliefs and that lots of people can have different ones.
DeleteI would explain that different people believe different things and that any one of those folks are as likely to be right as anyone else. All we can truly do is base our own beliefs on the things that we know to be true and learn from other people who have different experiences and beliefs.
ReplyDeleteHi Bernice, I appreciate the way you explained this. I agree that there is no right or wrong to beliefs, as they're based upon what we've learned- which is different for everyone. That's why learning from others is especially important in life, it's an ever changing journey for each of us, and it can influence or contradict all sorts of beliefs we've had or may have.
DeleteI would try to relate to the student but still explain that there are different beliefs and ways of thinking. From my understanding as a born and raised Catholic, Buddhism is more centered around finding peace. Finding peace and comfort in that we won't always be around, bringing more reasons to do/be better while we're still are around.
ReplyDeleteHi Denise I was raised catholic as well. I agree what you said, in Buddhism they focus on peace in life and not so much what happens in the afterlife..
DeleteHello Denise! As someone who was also raised Catholic, I understand your perspectives towards Buddhism. Since Catholicism believes in the existence of a Heaven, relating Buddhism to a belief that strives to find peace in endings or things that wont' always be around helps create a different perspective in comparison to Heaven's eternity after death.
DeleteHi Denise! I agree that they are just looking at things through different lenses. It's cool to see how the same question can feel like a heavy, sad thing to one person and a completely peaceful reality to someone else.
DeleteThe Sensei wasn't sad because his beliefs helped him accept life and death peacefully without expecting a heaven. I would explain that Christianity and Buddhism have different views of the afterlife, but both teach compassion, kindness, and living a meaningful life.
ReplyDeleteHey Kayday!! I really enjoyed reading your post. I really agree on how the Sensei has accepted the life after death on his beliefs rather than believing that their is a heaven. I really like your point on Christianity and Buddism both religions encourage compassion, kindness and give us meaning of life. Both share beliefs of the after life.
DeleteHi Kayday! I liked your explanation about how Sensei's beliefs lack an expectation of heaven, so from his point of view not having to be reborn is a comforting thought to him. I also liked how you noted the similarities some Christian and Buddhist beliefs have with each other. I'd also like to add that in both of these religions, the goal of what happens after death is typically shown to be a complete lack of the suffering the world can bring which could help the student understand Sensei's lack of sadness a bit more.
DeleteThe reason why the Sensei wasn't sad is because he never believed in a heaven to go to in the first place. Therefore he can't mourn something he never desired or believed in. He finds peace in living his life and becoming nothing afterwards. Christians are raised with the expectation to strive to reach heaven, and they live their life in a way to reach that final goal. For a Buddhist like this man, having a place to go after death wasn't ever a goal, so he feels no sadness in not accomplishing that. It's simply a matter of perspective on life that differs in both religions.
ReplyDeleteHi Mimi, i totally love when you said “Therefore he can’t mourn something he never desired or believed in” because you are right! It’s kinda like saying you can’t miss something you’ve never had. And yes, as someone who grew up christian the end goal of every lesson we learned is usually “how can we get into heaven” so there is a pressure already in that.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteMimi, Your comment really got me thinking a little bit about how our own perspectives that have been defined by our experiences and upbringings really play a major role in discussions like this!
DeleteIn reading posts from people who come from Christian/Catholic backgrounds here, I think it can be hard to fully understand the anxiety over doing all of the right things to get into heaven, but I found your comment very illuminating when it comes to the cultures that we're brought up in and the vastly different values that different people have been taught are most important.
I grew up in a christian household and I actually would’ve preferred to have grown up with the sensei’s perspective. Where you are just at peace with the fact that life just stops, there’s nothing else waiting after death. I would tell the student for him, it makes this life worthy of living to the fullest because there is no second chance so why not take the first. I think being able to see both perspectives from both these different people aka the student and the sensei really helps when it comes to respecting different beliefs.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteHi Dani,
DeleteAs someone who grew up Catholic, I totally understand what you mean when you say you would've preferred to grow up like the sensei. A lot of times growing up, I'd be scared to do something bad and somehow cost my place in heaven or whether if I was doing well at being a good person, or helping people, etc. I think heaven can be a really good thing for people to believe in, but also, as I've notice from my own childhood, sometimes it can cause some unwarranted anxiety about a future that's so far away.
Hi Dani! Being someone who also grew up around the belief that there exists a Heaven after death, I completely understand your perspective. If I were put in that student's shoes and hear you mention that "there is no second chance so why not take the first," my perspective would be enlightened. Although we are taught at a young age that Heaven is good, it also can entice some anxieties about performing as a kind and socially and morally "good" individual. By having the mindset of the Sensei, being able to live life without having such anxieties can help you live to the fullest of your abilities.
DeleteHi Dani!! I loved how you discussed the Sensei's perspective of how life is becoming more meaningful because it's the life we ever have. This help's us understand why he wasn't sad by the idea of nowhere to go after death. Yes, they both have very different beliefs but, it's really good that they take the time to show the understandings of what beliefs bring people peace and why do they believe in such.
DeleteHi Dani, I love how you showed interest in the sensei's perspective. I think it is a great example of how ideologies change and grow. I also like how you mentioed how the though of nothing would help for the student to live life to the fullest.
DeleteLike many things in the world, spiritual belief is highly personal, complicated, and subjective. While the idea of a Christian afterlife is comforting to many individuals and helpful in accepting one's mortality, the sensei may have found a similar comfort in the acceptance of the unknown and the possibility that everything simply ceases to exist in the afterlife.
ReplyDeleteNot knowing what will happen to us is something that is out of our control, so while people of certain beliefs are brought peace by feeling like there is a sense of control in one's ultimate fate through their Earthly actions, there is also a way of finding a sense of peace by simply letting go, valuing the time we have, and accepting whatever happens in the afterlife, which is why I think this wasn't a sad moment for the sensei.
Hi Ezra, I really like the way you put Buddhism into the context of living the best life you can with the time you have, I think that is really beautiful. I feel that this would be a satisfactory answer that highlights how the Sensei is content with his beliefs.
DeleteHi Erza, I love the way you've compared the two beliefs. I find it really interesting how both religions approach mortality in such opposing ways, yet they both offer peace to each person's life. The mindset of having control vs accepting that you have no control are both quite different, but what matters is what brings value to a person.
DeleteI don’t think I could offer the student much educational insight, with my current lack of knowledge about either religion. But I know that they have different values tied to their mortality, both of which bring them fulfillment in their lives. Their beliefs equally give them a sense of meaningfulness. It is beautiful that the sensei has found peace and acceptance in his life having a definitive end, and beautiful that the student believes in peace further beyond her life’s expectancy.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think I could explain to the student where the differences from their perspective come from. From the Christian (or Catholic, in my case) perspective, I can understand why the student seemed worried and sad---we're taught young that achieving heaven is this sort of "goal," or reward for our actions on Earth and there's a lot of anxiety around whether we're able to achieve heaven. To us, heaven is the next step in our adventure, it's not the end, whereas (and I'm not well-versed at all in Buddhism), it seems that Buddhism sees death the closing to our life. There's no worrying whether you did good enough in your life to get the "reward," because it wasn't ever an option---there's no "test" to pass. So I can totally see why the teacher was at peace. He can be satisfied that he lived a good life---not everything needs to keep going on forever. There's nothing wrong with either belief. They're just different ways of perceiving what happens at the end of life and that's totally okay.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteHi Lillian! As someone who isn't from a religious background, I'm so happy to see someone express what I don't quite have the language for: the anxiety of not being rewarded for one's actions. With your opinion in mind, I do wonder if you think the conversation with the Sensei inspired some contemplation from the student about if the anxiety of what will happen in the afterlife could be taking away from their sense of meaning in their waking life! I think this is why it's so important to talk to others about these things. To be able to reflect on our fulfillment and make lifestyle adjustments if necessary.
DeleteHi Lillian! I think your perspective as someone raised Catholic is very interesting! I also like your comparison of the end of life to a test. The way we perceive death and what it means dictates how we live our lives, and also how we feel and cope with death.
DeleteAs someone who was raised within a religious family that all shared the same beliefs, yet grew up surrounded by others who had vastly different beliefs than my own, both reactions within the conversation are entirely valid. Being raised Catholic, the mindset that performing good deeds throughout the entirety of your life can ensure you a rewarding/ everlasting afterlife in Heaven had been instilled in my way of thinking from an extremely young age. As a result of this, it at first seems hard to imagine any other outcomes for your life after death. Yet, after meeting others who grew up on different religious beliefs, being able to recognize these differences made it easier to understand the differences of religion and beliefs throughout several cultures. In order to explain to the student why I think the Sensei showed no sadness about not having a "heaven" to enter after death, I would say that is because the Sensei and student grew up and were surrounded by different beliefs. Although both give a sense of peace after death, one belief (Christianity) does so in a way that grants an eternal paradise while the other brings peace in the fact that the person was able to live life to the fullest before reaching its end.
ReplyDeleteHi Krystal
DeleteI really resonate with your perspective, especially since you shared your personal background growing up Catholic. It makes total sense why the Christian student in the scenario would feel that initial sadness—when you are taught from day one that peace equals an eternal reward, the alternative sounds empty at first. I love how you pointed out that the Sensei's peace comes from knowing he lived life to the fullest. It frames the Buddhist/Shinto perspective not as "missing out" on something, but as being entirely complete right here in the present.
I never grew up religious or never really thought of myself being apart of a certain religion group. But, this is something I would say to the student, neither of the Sensei or the student are wrong, more just fundamentally different. When the student asked where he goes after death he's asking a question thats more to his christian faith. Christians understand that a person of that faith has an identity that can continue after death so people always question why and to wonder where the person will go after death. The student interpreted the word "nowhere" as emptiness because in her faith she is taught to believe that this eternal life and not believing in such can be very sad. In the Sensei's eyes it's more of letting go and brings peace.
ReplyDeleteHi Whimsy! It’s interesting how a single word like 'nowhere' can mean something totally different depending on how you look at life. It isn't about one of them being wrong, it's just that they're finding their comfort in completely different places.
DeleteHi Whimsy, I really like how you pointed out that no one is wrong in this situation, yet they both have different beliefs. I also like how your comparison shows how one thought process brings peace while the other brings fear.
DeleteAs someone who grew up in a Christian household, I can see how the idea of nothingness at death could bring someone distress if one believes in there being an afterlife. However, from my currently limited understanding of Buddhism, the spiritual goal is to break away from the cycle of rebirth. The way that I would try to explain it to the student is that the idea of having nowhere to go when he dies brings Sensei the same comfort and peace that heaven would to her, so there is no reason to be sad from his perspective.
ReplyDeleteHi Dani, You made an excellent point by bringing in the concept of the cycle of rebirth! A lot of people outside of Buddhism don't realize that breaking away from that cycle rebirth is actually the ultimate goal, not a punishment. I love how you connected that to the Sensei's peace. You’re totally right—what looks like "nothingness" or a dead end to the Christian student is actually the ultimate liberation and achievement for the Sensei. Framing it as two different versions of comfort is a great connection.
DeleteIt seems like they were just speaking two different languages of peace. For the student, peace is found in the comfort of a promise for the future, but for the Sensei, peace is found in accepting the present moment as enough. I think showing respect means acknowledging that both perspectives are just different ways of finding comfort in the unknown.
ReplyDeleteHey Mona! Amazing summary of your thoughts on this subject - straight to the point and well put. The perspective about accepting death in the present vs. the future really stood out to me too!!
DeleteTo the Christian student, life is like a pilgrim traveling across the sea to reach a beautiful, permanent shore (Heaven). To the Sensei, life is like a wave on the ocean. The wave rises, experiences the world, and eventually crashes and dissolves back into the water. The wave hasn't disappeared, and it hasn't gone 'somewhere else'—it has simply returned to the ocean it was always a part of.
ReplyDeleteHey Shahab, it was wonderful how you compared the two belief systems with the use of an analogy. The way you compared the Christian view to a journey and the Buddhist view to a wave going back to the ocean helps make things clear as to why the Sensei wasn’t scared or sad about death. I guess the point here is that although different, both beliefs provide peace and purpose in life, and this is one thing that should be acknowledged and respected.
DeleteWow, amazing descriptive analogy Shahab!! A more beautiful way of what I said similarly - that although Sensei’s answer is different from the Christian-norm, it doesn’t mean the end result is different. Your concluding sentence sums it all up best though since at the end of the day death doesn’t matter to anyone except for individuals themselves. An aspect in life where your self matters more than any one else - instead of the usually pushed altruistic ways of thinking - you die for no one else but you.
DeleteI find that it seemed almost as if the sensei did not fear death even without a heaven because of his belief system; he had peace. Unlike Christian beliefs of Heaven, the sensei never had that ideology to begin with Even though every religion has a different outlook on the afterlife, every version is what brings someone their own peace.
ReplyDeleteHi Costal Curiosity! I really like your point that the Sensei didn't fear death because his beliefs already gave him peace. I also agree that since he never believed in heaven the way Christians do, he wouldn't feel like he was missing something. Your last sentence really stood out to me because it reminds us that different religions can provide comfort in different ways, and understanding those differences is an important part of respecting other people's beliefs.
DeleteI would tell that the reason of the Sensei's being happy lies in his different understanding of death from Christian one. For example, according to Buddhism, people should aim not at getting into the heaven after their deaths, but to enlightenment that will enable them to escape the cycle of rebirths. Hence, the notion of "having nowhere to go" can be perceived as something neutral, rather than tragic. At the same time, I would thank the student for her concern and for her willingness to share her views on the problem that stem from her Christianity and the importance of heaven for the religion. Finally, I would emphasize that both beliefs are good for comprehension of the Sensei's feeling happy and do not have to be evaluated in order to comprehend the reason behind it. Different religious affiliations lead to different sources of consolation, and respect of such differences enables people to learn from each other without judgment of what belief is right or wrong. Appreciation of others' perspectives is integral for anthropology studies.
ReplyDeleteSophie Sol
ReplyDeleteIf I had to respond to a Christian student about a Buddhist’s afterlife and why the Sensei wasn’t mad - I’d start by explaining that although he said he will go nowhere after death, that doesn’t equate to saying he won’t be in an afterlife. I can also understand how one wouldn’t be sad about that since having “nowhere” to go after death seems more peaceful than just heaven or hell. We don’t need a destination to die, we just do.
ReplyDeleteIn respect to the Christian girl, I would also tell her that even if the Sensei meant nowhere as “nothing”, that it’s up to each individual how they accept death. And as much as she wants to spread her belief in Jesus in order to “save” Sensei from nothingness, everyone’s path to Christianity (whether or not they end up walking it or not) is up to them, their time, and their relationship to Christianity - no one else should worry about that other than the person who’s exploring their sense of religion/spirituality.
I think the sensei wasn't sad because his beliefs had taught him that it's basically how life goes. It taught him to accept death as something everyone has to go through some point in life. In his culture he didn't believe people need a heaven to find peace. This is a different way of viewing life. It is very different from Christian and Catholic views. I would have to explain to them how different religions have different beliefs of what happens after death and it's okay. We should all respect each others beliefs and be understanding of each other.
ReplyDelete