"Sensei, do you go to heaven when you die?" "No... Bhuddists have no where to go."

Sunday, July 26, 2026

Week 3: Functions of Lore and Fairytales

Many humans take pleasure in being terrified.

Not me.  I’m not one of them.  You can’t pay me to watch a horror movie. 

The last horror/psychological thriller I believe I watched (and yes, I’m dating myself) is the *original* movie “Amityville Horror”, which hit theaters in 1979.  It gave me nightmares for weeks and I still, to this day, cringe when I hear the name “Jody”.

 

I will admit that Halloween is a difficult time for me.  The TV, streaming services and theaters are jam-packed with horror movies.  I stick with “Beetlejuice”, “Hocus Pocus”, and “It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown” and generally avoid everything else that inspires true terror.

But the success of the horror/psychological video genre suggests that I am perhaps in the minority.  We have a multitude of options to scare the living daylights out of us, everything from the classics of Alfred Hitchcock and vampire/werewolf movies, to the psychological thrillers like The Shining, Misery, and The Ring, to “slasher” movies like Halloween, Scream, and Saw.

[shudder]

Even though I can’t personally watch these forms of entertainment, that doesn’t stop me from looking at this practice with the eye of an anthropologist and wondering where this relationship with “terror” came from. 

One possible candidate is stories of “lore”.  We see examples of this in your readings for this class.  One classic example is “Dracula”, or the rise of vampire lore. 

The rise of vampire lore originated via the conjunction of two factors.

1.  The first was the individual Vlad Drăculea (or “Vlad the Impaler”).  He was born in Transylvania, Romania and controlled his region for nearly 30 years, from 1448 and 1477 (late Middle Ages).  He was known for killing his enemies by driving a wooden stake into their chest.  From there we wander into legend (i.e., facts are questionable), with stories of him “consuming” his victims by dipping bread into bowls of their blood.  While there are those who argue that he wasn’t the source of the character “Dracula”, it is hard to deny the parallels.

 

2.  There are a number of pathological conditions and diseases that seem to be connected with the rise of vampire lore.  One is called porphyria, which is a blood disorder.  Symptoms include the blistering of the skin when exposed to the sun, abdominal pain and seizures.  Before the advent of modern medicine, temporary relief could be achieved by consuming blood.  Another disease that is connected to the rise of vampire lore is tuberculosis, the symptoms of which included pale skin, coughing up blood, weight loss and a slow death. 



Combine these two events, the legend of “Vlad the Impaler” and diseases that involved blood in some way, and you have a logical pathway driven by fear for the rise of “vampire lore”.

But were the stories just stories? Or did they serve a story-telling function for these communities? These are important for us to explore as anthropologists as it helps us not just recognize these belief systems but to *understand WHY* they arise.

Some possible functions include:

1.  Means of Coping:  These tales can serve as a “coping mechanism” to deal with otherwise strange and unexplained deaths of family and community members.  This is a key function of belief systems of all sorts and offers a great example of how beliefs can form when other answers are not available.

2.  Fear of the “Other”:  Stories like this might help protect the community from outsiders bringing the disease into their communities.  If the community was relatively isolated, then contagious diseases (like tuberculosis) would require someone from outside the community to “import” the disease.  Stories that inspired fear in those “outsiders” might protect the community from those diseases.

3.  Social Control:  Stories might also serve as a means of “social control” as vampire lore often contained themes of “deviant behavior”.  This could include sexual behavior or even women behaving “independently” or not being sufficiently subservient. This could produce a result similar to “witch accusations” in that people would be inclined to follow strict social rules to avoid being accused of being a “vampire”.

These are only three possibilities of potentially many.

Understand that this same analysis can be run on any belief system or “lore”, and that leads us to your prompt for this discussion:

Discussion prompt:  Identify a type of traditional “lore” or fairy-tale that inspired fear in some way.  Briefly explain the lore and then try to figure out at least two possible functions for these stories to the communities.  (5 pts).  If you want to earn an additional 5 pts, respond to another student post with a critique (positive or negative) of their analysis.

Have fun with this!

19 comments:

  1. One of the most famous and one of my personal favorites is the "lore" Of La Llorona. This tale is rooted in Hispanic culture and has been passed down for decades. La Llorona, or "The Weeping Woman," is a story about a woman who drowned her two children because of the anger she felt toward their father, who abandoned her. After realizing that she had killed her children, she became overtaken with guilt and sadness. After her passing, her spirit walked the earth in search of her children. Many people say that they can still hear her cry if close to lakes or rivers, and if you hear that, run because that means she is ready to take the lives of more children. Some people believe that this story was used as a scare tactic to keep their children away from bodies of water to avoid drowning. Others believe that this story teaches that actions have consiquences and the importance of protecting your family.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I loved your discussion of La Llorona. I definitely think that one of the purposes of the legend was to keep kids away from water sources since there was a danger of them drowning. Also, I loved that you emphasized the fact that this legend shows us that our actions have consequences and that we should take good care of our families. It is fascinating how an intimidating legend manages to both entertain and educate at the same time.

      Delete
    2. I learned about the story of La Llorona as a child and it's been one of my favorite myths ever since. I liked both of the functions of this myth that you mentioned, drowning is one of the most common causes of death in the world so to avoid children going towards a body of water, especially at night, it would make sense to place a terrifying figure that lures children to their deaths there.

      Delete
  2. The Wendigo is a scary monster from Native American (Algonquian) legends—a skinny, frozen, corpse-like creature driven by an insatiable hunger for human flesh. According to the lore, a person turns into a Wendigo if they become overly greedy or resort to cannibalism to survive a harsh winter.

    This story served two major functions for the community. First, it acted as a tool for social control. In freezing winters when food was scarce, survival depended entirely on cooperation, so scaring people with the threat of turning into a monster enforced strict rules around sharing and prevented greed. Second, it functioned as an environmental warning. It warned community members about the severe psychological dangers of starvation and extreme winter isolation, reminding everyone to prepare ahead and stay vigilant against winter psychosis.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Shahab! I completely agree with your post. The part about turning into a Wendigo if greedy especially plays into the bit about keeping the community cooperating. After hearing these stories, there would likely not be as many people willing to be overly greedy, so in times of uncertain survival they would already by primed against being greedy. Also, just the description of Wendigo's as frozen corpses would be horrifying enough to warn people to be careful in that sort of weather.

      Delete
  3. Hi Shahab Qadir, the Wendigo is definitely one of my favorite cryptids. I like how you metioned that its creation was for social control. I never actually thought about that. It would make sense, though, if it was to prevent people from eating too much during food scarcity. I had always heard about the version of the Wendigo where it was a skinwalker that lived in the Appalachian Mountains. I always just assumed it was a scare tactic from parents to keep their kids from going out at night.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The first old story of legend that instilled fear is known as "La Llorona" which translates to "The Weeping Woman". This is based on the fact that in the legend, she drowns her children and continues to wander around rivers and lakes calling out for them. In most cases, many stories indicate that she abducts children especially when they are alone at night. I believe that this story played two major roles; the first role played is the safety precaution whereby it kept children away from areas where they could drown. Secondly, the story was used for social control because it taught children to be obedient and remain close to home. From the perspective of anthropology, this is much more than a horror story.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree about the legend being used to keep children away from water. Many European stories share similarities to La Llorona, especially that of the Rusalka. Rusalka are from Russian/Balkan lore, and are female water spirits that drown those who come near their streams. Many times they are the spirits of young women and children who were murdered in the river, accidentally drowned, or drowned themselves due to a lover's fight. They serve almost the same story, showing that it was likely a common theme or idea to keep children safe.

      Delete
    2. La Llorona is a very popular piece of folklore that I remember being very interested in when I first learned about it. I think you make a good point about how this tale was used to bring about social control, especially in youth, about obedience and remaining close to home. However, I do also think La Llorona's story could be used as a way to interpret grief as well. Her compelling story could also parallel themes within maternal women who have suffered child lose and grief.

      Delete
  5. The story I will share is incredibly depressing and scary. It has references to slavery, zombies, and suicide. You have been warned.

    I first heard this story four or so years ago, on a podcast called Lore (Highly recommend). Episode 26, titled "Brought Back" discusses the origins of zombies and zombie lore. The modern concept of the zombie originated among the enslaved people of Haiti. Many came from West Africa and brought their beliefs with them when they were sold into slavery. Their cultural beliefs about death combined with a fear and hatred of slavery. Many believed that death was their only release from slavery and the way to return to their homelands. This hopelessness and lack of control might have led to mass suicides if not for another belief that censured such behaviors. Although some still committed suicide, others were restrained by the fear of becoming a zombie. In becoming a zombie, they would continue to work on the plantations forever. In addition to discouraging suicide, the zombie beliefs also discourage trust in outsiders. One case from 1962 demonstrates this. A man, Clairvius Narcisse, was declared dead by two American doctors and buried. 18 years later, however, he reappeared. He claimed that he had been poisoned by his (now deceased) brother and that he had been drugged and forced to work on a sugar plantation. Over 200 people confirmed his identity. Although he was initially poisoned by his brother, Narcisse's circumstances can be attributed both to the doctors who declared him dead and to the strange men who dug him up. The warning that one draws is to not trust outsiders, especially those who would exploit you.

    https://loretranscripts.tumblr.com/post/186399316653/lore-episode-26-brought-back-transcript-25th

    ReplyDelete
  6. One piece of folklore that has always stood out to me is the legend of La Llorona, i chose this one because of my personal curiosity of it. The “Weeping Woman.” The story tells of a woman who wanders near rivers crying for her children after drowning them. Parents have passed down this story for generations to warn children not to wander near rivers or stay out alone at night. I think one function of this lore is social control because it encourages children to obey their parents and avoid dangerous places. Another function is as a means of coping, since the story provides an explanation for tragic accidents involving children near water and helps communities make sense of those events. Even though the story isn’t literally true, it continues to influence behavior and has remained an important part of many cultures.

    ReplyDelete
  7. One tale of folklore that I thought about was the story of Krampus, which originated in Europe. I remember when the Krampus movie had come out in 2015 and, still being a Santa-believer at the time, refused to watch that movie out of fear. However, looking back it is interesting to see the parallels between Santa and Krampus. While Santa (or Saint Nicholas) is a being who rewarded children with gifts for behaving well, Krampus is a half-goat half-demon entity that comes to punish misbehaving children by swatting them, stuffing them into a sack, and taking them to the underworld. I think one function that this folklore serves is to maintain a set of societal standards within children. By passing down this scary story, children are more likely to behave and follow community/societal rules and grow to be more mature. I think another function this tale serves is to bring the community together. Many communities hold festivals to ward off bad winter spirits like Krampus through celebratory festivals, creating a strong sense of camaraderie.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Krystel! Your analysis of Krampus as a tool for enforcing societal standards through fear is spot-on. It's also fascinating how communities channel that collective dread into vibrant seasonal festivals that foster deep social bonds. That dual purpose makes this European folklore a classic anthropological example of keeping both individual children and the wider community in line.

      Delete
  8. When I was 11 years old, the movie Krampus came out. I remember hearing about the legend previously and it was pretty silly in my mind, until I watched it on the big screen.
    Krampus is like the anti Santa Claus. While Santa comes bearing gifts and treats for the good children, Krampus is a christmas demon who punishes the naughty children by stuffing them in his sack and taking them away or whipping them with branches.
    This myth functions as a method of behavioral control for children. If the threat of no visits from Santa isn't enough, the story of being visited by the terrifying Krampus will surely keep children in line. Having an evil figure for christmas time also keeps Saint Nicholas as a sanctified, "good-guy" figure.

    ReplyDelete
  9. One type of traditional lore that was used to inspire fear is the story of the Baba Yaga from Slavic folklore. Baba Yaga is usually described as an old witch who lives alone in a magical hut with chicken legs in the middle of the forest. She is known for kidnapping or eating people. Many of the tales about her are about children who wander into the woods and get eaten. These stories were used to warn people, mainly children, that the forest was an incredibly dangerous place. The function of these stories was to teach children to stay nearby their homes and to avoid wandering into the dangerous forests where they could get lost or hurt. Another way these stories were uses was to reinforce good behavior by encouraging children to listen to their parents and respect rules. For example, they could do this by saying that Baba Yaga would come and eat the children if they didn't listen to their parents.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Shanthi! I liked your explanation of the myth and how you related it to maybe functioning as a lesson for children and social control in general. However, I think both your functions. were essentially reiterating the same point, talking about keeping children in line and teaching them safety. Maybe they also used the tale to cope with or explain mysterious disappearances in the community.

      Delete
  10. In Irish folklore, the Banshee is a terrifying female spirit or fairy whose piercing, wailing shrieks echo through the night to foretell an impending death within a family. Anthropologically, this frightening legend served crucial functions for historical communities by acting as a psychological coping mechanism to make sense of sudden, unexplained losses and tragedies without modern medical answers. Additionally, because the lore was traditionally tied to specific prominent family bloodlines, it functioned as a tool for social control that reinforced strong kin solidarity, cultural heritage, and strict adherence to community obligations.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Across medieval/early modern Europe in many countries like Ireland, Scotland, and Scandinavia especially, people believed fairies could secretly swap a human infant for one of their own. They were called changelings, and signs of one includes failure to grow, developmental delays, seizures, or sudden personality changes. Parents believed their real child had been taken and the sickly one left behind was an imposter. This sometimes leads to disturbing "tests" meant to make the fairies return the real child. This l likely traces back to unexplained conditions like cerebral palsy, autism, or Down syndrome in a pre-medical world.
    Function 1: Like vampire lore, this gave parents a way to explain an unexplainable illness or disability without taking the blame themselves. They projected the cause onto fairies rather than making it their own fault.
    Function 2. In communities with little to no resources, a severely disabled child was a heavy burden. By looking at the child as a monster or not really yours, the belief may have given communities permission in their minds to stop caring without it considering it as neglect. It brings not just comfort, but also rationalizes difficult choices.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great discussion! Loved how all of you are grasping the "function" aspect of this activity!

    ReplyDelete

Week 5: Applied Anthropology and the Middle East

  1983 Israeli-Lebanon Peace Treaty that collapsed a year later . The Arab-Israeli conflict is a regular part of our news cycle and has be...